As I said when I reviewed Dark Victory I feel that I may've misjudge Bete Davis on the three films I have watched her in up to that point. In The Letter and especially in Jezebel and The Little Foxes she played a manipulative woman who would use what she had to get what she wanted and she didn't care who she hurt along the way. But in Dark Victory and the next film on our list All This and Heaven Too she plays the innocent in this case an English woman teaching French in an American Girls School who is victim of gossip from her students after they found out she was in a French prison. To dispel any gossip or rumors, Davis' Henrietta - better known throughtout the film as Madamoiselle, tells them the story of her becoming the governess to a Duke and Duchess played by Charles Boyer and Barbara O'Neil who are known throughout the film as Monsieur and Madame. From Madamoiselle's appointment the couple are arguing and the children are reacting to the friction in their parents' marriage luckily she is able to calm them down and quickly she becomes a friend to them. With Monsieur spending a lot of time with his children he quickly strikes up a friendship with Madamoiselle to which Madame reads too much into and becomes extremely jeaolus when the two attend a concert together along with one of the girls and their appearance gets them into the newspapers. Eventually Madame throws Madamoiselle out of the house and she goes to stay with a friend while she waits for her former employer to write her a letter of recomendation. However the letter never comes and when the Duke confronts his wife she tells him she will never write it and in a fit of rage he kills her. Madamoiselle and Monsieur are both arrested on suspicion of commiting the murder together however he poisons himself and without enough evidence to link her to the crime she is let out of prison and thanks to a friendship with the American consulate lands herself the job at the girls school. The film ends with the girls hugging their new teacher probably because they've got out of a two hour French lesson.
In my opinion All This and Heaven Too would've been better if Davis had played the Madame, jealous of her husband's relationship with the new young nanny and then she could've used her influence over the servants and the members of the town to drive the new housekeeper out. However Davis instead chose to take the more personable role of Henrietta and she does excel eventually standing up to the Madame and recieving her marching orders however it is not as commanding a performance as some of her others and it did not get her an Oscar nomination. The only Oscar nomination went o O'Neil who was absolutely superb as the paranoid and uptight Duchess who throws wild accusations all over the place and eventually recieves her commeupance. Boyer again plays one of those characters who you're not quite sure about and in the end he reveals his true colours by killing his wife and then making it look like a robbery. What I probably liked best about the film was its campy nature from the way it tried to convince us that we were really watching 19th Century France to the creepy performances from some of the suspicious servants in the hosue to the design of the Duke and Duchess' mansion itself. But what spoilt it for me was the performance of all the child actors who had pretty hefty roles and none were really good in them either coming off as precocious, annoying or both. My other criticism would be that it took far too long getting to the point where Boyer and Davis realised their feelings for one another and then the murder scenes and their fallout were rather rushed. Still a good film, All this and Heaven Too would've been much better if it had been slimmed down and if Davis was allowed to play the villainess.
No comments:
Post a Comment